Friday, September 28, 2007

more software >> more options >> learn less

I have thought a lot about the post I made about powerpoint a couple of days ago and realised that I am finding myself going backward in the use and application of software. a few years ago the functional skill of pupils reaching the end of KS3 was pretty good, in that they would know what was need to present information in a clear and concise way whether through the use of words or images.
there software knowledge was easily measurable and obvious.
I have just spent the morning teaching macromedia (well adobe now) fireworks, and the results to the untrained eye look pretty good, but the problem is the student don't really know why they are doing what they do.

it could be argued that it doesn't matter (if it looks right it is right) but I think it does, with every new piece of software and upgrade the thought process becomes less and the software create the answers for you so you don't have to think.
I have even go to the lengths of getting pupils to draw out how they want their finished work to look on paper before they touch a computer then they have to make the computer do what they want it to do, it makes it harder but the end result is better.

2 comments:

davidthedesigner said...

I really, really can't believe that I'd ever, ever get into a discussion about Powerpoint, but there are some observations that might interest you on Russell Davies blog http://russelldavies.typepad.com/planning/2007/09/powerpoint-as-1.html

surf98/dgeorge said...

Thanks David,
I know what you mean, I had to think hard (powerpoint?) before I posted, but the functional skill or lack of it thing made me do it!
I thought it (.ppt) would completely disappear a few years ago but, again have been proved wrong.
I'm off to check Russell D's ideas.
David
PS (I thought you were away from the blog-sphere for a while).